5 Signs You're Using AI as a Crutch (And How to Fix It)

Published: January 27, 2025

Author: Prismer Team

The Tool That Thinks for You

AI assistants like ChatGPT have become indispensable for millions of people. Need to draft an email? Ask AI. Stuck on a coding problem? Ask AI. Want to understand a complex topic? Ask AI.

There's nothing wrong with using powerful tools. But somewhere along the way, a subtle shift happens for many users. The tool that was supposed to augment your capabilities starts to replace them. You stop thinking through problems yourself. You stop struggling productively with new concepts. You stop building the mental muscles that make you genuinely capable.

You're not using AI as a tool anymore. You're using it as a crutch.

The difference matters enormously. A tool extends your capabilities while you remain the capable one. A crutch compensates for a weakness—and if you rely on it long enough, that weakness deepens.

Here are five signs that you've crossed the line, and what to do about it.

Sign #1: You Can't Explain What AI Told You

The test is simple: After AI gives you an answer, could you explain it to someone else in your own words? Not recite it—actually explain it, adapting to their questions and confusion?

If you find yourself thinking "I'd need to ask AI again to explain it properly," that's a red flag. You haven't learned the concept—you've just borrowed AI's understanding temporarily.

This is what psychologists call the illusion of explanatory depth. We think we understand things better than we actually do, especially when we've recently encountered a clear explanation. The AI's confident, well-structured response creates a feeling of understanding that evaporates when you try to reconstruct it yourself.

The Fix: The Feynman Test

After AI explains something, close the chat and try to explain the concept as if you were teaching it to a complete beginner. Write it out or say it aloud. Where you get stuck or vague, that's where you don't actually understand.

Then—and this is crucial—don't just ask AI to explain again. Ask yourself specific questions about your confusion points first. What exactly don't you understand? What would you need to know to fill the gap? Then return to AI with those targeted questions.

The effort of articulation is itself a learning event. It forces your brain to organize and retrieve knowledge, strengthening your actual understanding rather than your feeling of understanding.

Sign #2: You Ask AI Before You Think

How long do you sit with a question before reaching for AI? A minute? Thirty seconds? Do you sometimes type the question while it's still forming in your mind?

When AI becomes your first resort rather than your last, you're outsourcing the most valuable part of learning: the struggle.

Cognitive science has a name for this: desirable difficulty. When you struggle with a problem before seeing the solution, you're priming your brain to learn. The effort of attempted retrieval and reasoning, even when unsuccessful, creates mental structures that make the eventual answer stick.

When you skip this struggle and go straight to AI, you get the answer faster. But you also get less learning. The neural pathways that would have formed during your struggle never develop.

The Fix: The 5-Minute Rule

Before asking AI anything substantive, set a timer for 5 minutes. During those 5 minutes:

Write down what you already know about the problem
Generate at least two possible answers or approaches
Identify specifically what you're uncertain about

You'll be surprised how often you can figure things out yourself—or at least get much closer than you expected. And when you do eventually ask AI, you'll have a much better framework for integrating the answer into your existing knowledge.

The goal isn't to avoid AI. It's to ensure that when you use it, you're building on your own thinking rather than replacing it.

Sign #3: You Ask the Same Questions Repeatedly

Look at your AI chat history. Do you see the same topics coming up again and again? Are you asking AI to re-explain things you asked about last week, last month, or last year?

This is the clearest sign that you're consuming information rather than learning it. You're treating AI like a reference book you never have to close—always available, never internalized.

There's a name for this pattern: information outsourcing. Instead of committing knowledge to your own memory, you're storing it externally. The problem is that externally stored knowledge isn't available when you need it most—during conversations, while making decisions, when the internet is down, or when you're trying to make creative connections between ideas.

The Fix: Spaced Retrieval Practice

When AI teaches you something you expect to need again, don't just read it and move on. Take these steps:

Summarize it yourself immediately after reading
Test yourself later that day: What did AI explain about X?
Test yourself again after a few days
If you can't recall it, try hard before looking it up—then note what you forgot

This is called spaced repetition, and it's one of the most powerful learning techniques known. The increasing intervals between retrieval attempts force your brain to strengthen the memory trace each time.

Better yet: use a tool that builds this practice into the learning process itself. (That's exactly what we built at Prismer—more on that later.)

Sign #4: Your First Draft Is AI's Draft

Whether you're writing an email, a report, a piece of code, or a creative piece—does AI write the first version, with you editing afterward?

This workflow feels efficient. AI handles the blank page problem; you refine and personalize. What could be wrong with that?

The problem is that the first draft is where the real thinking happens. When you stare at a blank page and figure out what you actually want to say, you're exercising crucial cognitive skills: organizing thoughts, making arguments, finding your voice. When AI does this for you, those muscles atrophy.

There's also a subtler issue: AI's first draft shapes your thinking in ways you don't notice. The structure AI chooses, the examples it includes, the angle it takes—all of this becomes your starting point. Your "editing" often becomes minor adjustments within a framework you didn't choose.

The Fix: Reverse the Flow

Write your own first draft before involving AI. It doesn't have to be polished—it just has to be yours. Capture your initial thoughts, your structure, your voice.

Then use AI strategically:

Ask it to critique your draft, not replace it
Ask for alternatives to specific sections you're unsure about
Ask it to strengthen your existing arguments, not generate new ones
Use it to check for gaps in your reasoning

The result will be distinctly yours, enhanced by AI—rather than AI's output with your fingerprints on it.

Sign #5: You Feel Anxious Without AI Access

Imagine you're working on something important, and your internet goes down. Or you hit ChatGPT's rate limit. Or the service is temporarily unavailable.

How do you feel? Mildly inconvenienced, like when any tool is unavailable? Or genuinely anxious, like part of your capability has been amputated?

If AI unavailability feels like a crisis, that's a sign you've become dependent in an unhealthy way. You've built a workflow—and possibly an identity—around a tool you can't control.

This isn't just about productivity. It's about self-efficacy—your belief in your own capability. When that belief becomes contingent on access to an external tool, you've given away something important.

The Fix: Planned Disconnection

Regularly work without AI access—not because you're punishing yourself, but because you're building confidence in your own capabilities.

Try these exercises:

AI-free deep work blocks: Spend 2-3 hours on meaningful work without AI assistance. You'll discover you're more capable than you thought.
Solve a problem the hard way: When you're tempted to ask AI, use traditional resources instead—documentation, books, asking colleagues. Reconnect with your problem-solving instincts.
Write without AI for a week: All emails, all documents, all communication. Notice what you can actually do on your own.

The goal isn't to abandon AI—it's to ensure you remain a capable human who uses AI, rather than an AI-dependent human who can't function without it.

The Deeper Pattern: Offloading vs. Augmenting

All five signs share a common thread: they represent cognitive offloading rather than cognitive augmentation.

Cognitive offloading means shifting mental work to an external tool. Some offloading is fine—we use calculators for arithmetic, calendars for scheduling, GPS for navigation. These tools handle routine tasks so we can focus our mental energy elsewhere.

But there's a crucial distinction: offloading routine tasks preserves your capabilities, while offloading core thinking degrades them.

Using a calculator doesn't make you worse at mathematical reasoning. But using AI to do your reasoning makes you worse at reasoning. Using GPS doesn't impair your ability to learn new routes when needed. But using AI to learn new things can impair your ability to learn.

Cognitive augmentation is different. It's using tools to enhance your own capabilities rather than replace them. It's using AI as a sparring partner for your thinking, not a substitute for it.

The Right Way to Use AI for Learning

AI can be a powerful learning tool—if you use it correctly. Here's the difference:

Crutch Use (Weakens You)

Ask AI → Read answer → Move on
Let AI do the thinking
Rely on AI as external memory
Skip the struggle
Use AI output as your own

Tool Use (Strengthens You)

Think first → Ask AI → Test yourself
Use AI to challenge your thinking
Use AI to identify what to memorize, then memorize it
Embrace productive struggle, use AI for targeted help
Use AI to enhance your original work

The pattern is clear: effective AI use keeps you at the center, with AI as a powerful assistant. Crutch use puts AI at the center, with you as a passive recipient.

How Prismer Helps You Use AI as a Tool, Not a Crutch

At Prismer, we've built a learning platform specifically designed to prevent crutch use and encourage genuine learning.

Built-In Retrieval Practice

After Prismer explains a concept, it doesn't just let you move on. It tests you immediately with quiz questions that require you to actually recall and apply what you learned. This isn't optional—it's baked into the learning flow.

The result: you can't just passively consume and fool yourself into thinking you've learned. You get immediate feedback on whether you actually understood.

Learning Slides, Not Walls of Text

Prismer presents information in structured learning slides with clear goals and organized concepts. This format requires you to engage actively—making connections, following the logic, building understanding—rather than passively absorbing a polished essay.

Branch-Based Exploration

Instead of endless scrolling through a single chat, Prismer encourages branching into related topics. Each branch is a new opportunity to learn and test, creating an interconnected web of knowledge that you've actually earned through retrieval practice.

Your Learning, Visualized

Prismer shows you what you've learned and tested over time, making your knowledge growth visible. This isn't just motivating—it helps you identify gaps and revisit topics that need reinforcement.

The Bottom Line

AI is the most powerful learning tool humanity has ever created—or the most sophisticated crutch. Which one it becomes depends on how you use it.

If you recognize yourself in any of these five signs, don't panic. You're not broken, and you don't need to quit AI cold turkey. You just need to shift your relationship with it: from outsourcing your thinking to augmenting your capabilities.

The goal is to be a more capable person who uses AI, not a less capable person who depends on it.

Start Using AI the Right Way

Ready to transform AI from crutch to tool? Prismer is built from the ground up to support active learning. Every session includes retrieval practice, ensuring you actually learn—not just feel like you did.

Stop outsourcing your thinking. Start augmenting your capabilities.

Try Prismer Free — AI that makes you smarter, not dependent.